Ulysses Gets Censored Again; This Time by Apple

Apple’s strategy of censoring apps that contains content unsuitable for children is certainly defensible, but sometimes the results are ludicrous. A comic adaptation of James Joyce’s Ulysses was denied approval until the developer and artist made some changes, notably reframing the image below:

Come on, Apple, even the famous court decision overturning its censorship in the US made things pretty clear:

[W]hilst in many places the effect of Ulysses on the reader undoubtedly is somewhat emetic, nowhere does it tend to be an aphrodisiac.

This is really sad; Apple censoring a comic of one of the English language’s greatest novels, while still, fortunately, allowing that novel to be sold in ebook format via its iBookstore. Apple has set standards that are very difficult to enforce, and should really rethink the kind of stupidity they are leading to. Keep out porn, sure, but provide a parental control system so things such as this comic – and its subsequent episodes – can be distributed. The future of a lot of creative content is at stake here; Apple shouldn’t be the one arbitrarily deciding that a comic of a great novel is obscene just because there’s a penis in it.

In any case, the entire work – including all of the supporting information, which will be of help to any reader of Ulysses, is available on the web. And, by the way, the iPad app is free, so grab that too!

Five New Take Control eBooks about the iPad; Get iPad Basics for Free

Although the iPad is easy to pick up and start tapping on, it can be harder to avoid newbie mistakes, do useful work, enjoy your media, use email effectively, and set up secure network connections. To help iPad users solve all those problems and many more, TidBITS Publishing Inc. has released a five-volume set of ebooks comprising over 500 pages of real-world advice about the iPad. In contrast with traditional print books, these—and all other—Take Control ebooks can be read on the iPad or on any computer, and readers will receive free and discounted updates as the topics covered evolve.

The first ebook in the set, the 109-page Take Control of iPad Basics, by Tonya Engst, is available for free to help new users become comfortable with their iPads. The remaining ebooks go beyond the basics to focus on subtle details and provide the expert advice that sets the Take Control series apart. They can be purchased individually or together for $30 in an Improve Your iPad IQ bundle.

Here’s what the new ebooks are about:

• Take Control of iPad Basics, by Tonya Engst: The ebook helps readers decide which iPad and accessories to buy, points out the iPad’s buttons and ports, and explains the iPad’s multi-touch gestures. Engst also covers how to download apps, sync data and media, find your stuff, and avoid newbie mistakes. The ebook wraps up with a discussion of how to demo an iPad to interested friends and colleagues. In a blog post, technology consultant Tony Lawrence wrote, “I strongly recommend ‘Take Control of iPad Basics’ for all new and prospective iPad owners. I’ve been using my iPad night and day for weeks and I still learned things!” 109 pages, Free!

• Take Control of Working with Your iPad, by Joe Kissell: In this ebook, Kissell covers what you can do with Apple’s iWork suite—Pages, Numbers, and Keynote—and with many third-party apps. Readers will learn to manage contacts and calendars, take notes and write documents, create spreadsheets and presentations, and much more. Special topics include printing from the iPad and moving documents among apps and devices. 111 pages, $10

• Take Control of Media on Your iPad, by Jeff Carlson: This ebook goes beyond the basics while explaining how to download and read ebooks in iBooks, useful tricks for listening to audio in the iPod app, and how to use an iPad as a remote control for iTunes, the Apple TV, or consumer electronics. A free update will soon add coverage of videos, photos, and more. 65 pages, $10

• Take Control of Mail on the iPad, iPhone, and iPod touch, by Joe Kissell: For this title, Kissell provides real-world advice about using the Mail app on an iPad, iPhone, or iPod touch. He covers various email account options including Exchange, MobileMe, and Gmail; helps readers develop a real-world mobile email strategy that integrates with multiple devices and computers; explains the mechanics of sending and receiving mobile email; and provides essential troubleshooting advice. 96 pages, $10

• Take Control of iPad Networking & Security, by Glenn Fleishman: In this detailed and practical ebook, Fleishman looks deeply at how to network an iPad and keep its data safe from prying eyes. Along with Wi-Fi, 3G, and Bluetooth network advice, he explains how to transfer documents to and from an iPad, control remote computers, and reduce the chance of an iPad being hacked or stolen. 152 pages, $15

Are All iPad Buyers Egotistical?

In an article in today’s New York Times, titled, “Applause, Please, for Early Adopters,” journalist Damon Darlin makes some misplaced assertions about iPad purchasers, and some mistaken comparisons. He discusses those who have bought the iPad, and offers a comparison with the iPhone:

A tough lesson about buying early could have been learned by the iPhone’s first buyers back in 2007. Those early adopters paid $600 for a phone. Two months later, Apple dropped the price to $400. Then, in June 2009, it introduced a better version, with twice the storage, for $200, one-third the original’s price.

What he seems to ignore, however, is that the iPhone is subsidized by phone companies in a complex financial agreement where Apple gets money from AT&T in exchange for the customers’ lock-in to that company’s phone contracts. The comparison of apples and oranges does not shed any light on potential future prices of iPads.

Granted, many people buy tech devices because of a desire to be up-to-date and ahead of the curve, but comparing prices for the iPad with those of a cellphone is disingenuous. It would be fairer to compare its price with that of, say, a laptop. The latter’s price will drop, over time, as new models are released, and new features are added, but the change will not be drastic.

I wonder if the author buys hardcover books – after all, they are just for “early adopters” who can’t wait for the paperbacks. Or new albums, at full price, before they turn into “budget-priced” discs. Yes, people pay a premium for newness; there’s nothing new about that. Unfortunately, one journalist used a very bad example to point out this well-known fact.

Take a Stroll Through Apple’s iBookstore

In my latest Macworld article, I take a stroll through the aisles of Apple’s iBookstore, the gateway to buying ebooks on the iPad. It’s ok, but I have some reservations. Check it out if you’re interested in ebooks.

Hear Me Discuss the iPad on the Tech Night Owl Live

On this week’s all-star episode, the iPad remains front and center, as Apple reports selling 500,000 units the very first week. What this means is that the international rollout is delayed until May.

But that didn’t stop columnist Kirk McElhearn from having one sent by a friend in the U.S. to his home in France, and so he gives you his hands-on experiences, including a direct comparison with the Amazon Kindle and his evaluation of the forthcoming iPhone 4.0 update.

Cutting-edge commentator Daniel Eran Dilger, of Roughly Drafted Magazine, is on hand to address those rumors that Adobe is poised to sue Apple over such problems as the lack of support for Flash on Apple’s mobile platform, and the controversial change in the developer’s license. This revised agreement evidently blocks using cross-platform tools or Flash to build iPhone apps.

NOW PLAYING! April 15, 2010 — Kirk McElhearn and Daniel Eran Dilger

Amazon’s Kindle App for iPad vs Apple’s iBooks

One of the main reasons I wanted to buy Apple’s iPad is to use the device as an ebook reader. I’m a big reader, and have thousands of books, but would like to be able to read some books on a portable device. Aside from any discussion of the merits of this, I thought I would look at the two main apps for reading ebooks, Amazon’s Kindle and Apple’s iBooks. (I’m leaving aside the many other apps that allow you to read free ebooks, or those which offer limited catalogs. I’m just looking at the two that let you read the broadest selection. And I won’t discuss selection here either, because the iPad is too new to have the selection that Amazon offers.)

First, Amazon currently has the edge in device ubiquity, with a Kindle app for the iPhone and iPod touch, as well as for the iPad. Apple’s iBooks will, however, be available for these devices in the fall, when the company releases a new version of their software. Amazon also, however, lets you read ebooks on their own device – the Kindle – or on a Mac or PC, with a program that that works on those platforms. Apple will presumably follow suit, with a Mac version of iBooks in the fall, and perhaps even a Windows version.

But the main question remains that of display. Reading an ebook, you want the broadest range of display options, so you can get the maximum reading pleasure from the books you buy.

Dear New York Times: I Would Like to Pay for Your News, Please

So I got my iPad today. I’m impressed. (See the post below.)

But one thing I want to do is use it to read the news. As I wrote a while ago on Macworld, I think there are great opportunities to get people to pay for content – news and other types of web information – using this device.

So I downloaded the New York Times’ “Editors’ Choice” app, and I’m very disappointed. First, by the ads; there aren’t too many, yet, because this is new. But I’m sure there will be more. Second, by the limited number of stories available. I don’t want to read web sites with the iPad, unless they’re optimized for the device; but dedicated apps make sense.

However, if you don’t provide more news and no ads – for a fee – this app is essentially worthless. I don’t only want to read the stories you include, I want to read a lot of your stories (such as book reviews, but also stories from the archives).

So, please improve this app, then come up with a fair price. I’ll sign up right away.

An iPad in My Hands: First Impressions

I got my iPad today, shipped from the US. Rather than wait a month, I wanted to be able to check out this new device, and to be able to write about it as soon as possible. I’m looking forward to writing several articles about using the iPad for Macworld.

But first, I wanted to post some first impressions. Sure, there have been tons of iPad reviews, posted all over the web, and I don’t intend to write a full review, but rather just jot down some ideas that have crossed my mind after using the iPad for a few hours.

The device itself is very attractive, easy to hold, but it’s heavy. I can’t see using this while standing in the subway, or even using it for a long time without being able to rest it on something: your lap, a tilted case, or a table. Compared to the Kindle, the iPad is a heavyweight. The screen is glossy, which isn’t great, but it’s easy to find a good viewing angle. It doesn’t get very dirty during use, which surprises.

The display is amazing: bright, crisp, and fonts are very readable even at low sizes. (It’s 132 ppi, or about twice the resolution as a computer screen.) I can definitely see reading on this device for a long time.

Applications launch very quickly, for the most part, and are quite responsive. However, it’s clear that some apps I tried were rushed out and lack optimization; some apps have lag which surprises compared to the overall speed.

The built-in speaker, which is in the center of the device behind the aluminum back, sounds surprisingly good. I could see listening to music while using the device, just with the speaker, if I’m not too concerned about sound quality (ie, stereo sound). It is a great device for listening to audiobooks, and the sound of games and other interface feedback is excellent.

The iBooks app is very nice, but it’s pretty similar to the Kindle app. The selection of books available is much more limited than those from Amazon, and, while I’m a big reader, I couldn’t find any books that I really wanted to buy. There are too many publishers missing for now, but that will change soon. You can, however, get free books sourced from Project Gutenberg, and they are, for the most part, fine. (Though a complete Shakespeare is pretty much unusable because the table of contents is borked.)

What is most striking about this device is the impression I get of newness: not that the object itself is new, but that the way I’m using it is new. It’s very different from an iPhone or iPod touch, and it’s nothing like a computer. It really is a new category of device, or, as a friend said, the first “information appliance.”

I’ll post more after I’ve used the iPad for a few days. For now, I’m very, very impressed.