The Stupidity of Apple’s Lion Installer

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Google+Share on LinkedInEmail this to someone

This hasn’t been my week. I got this video freeze problem with my new Mac mini, and decided that reinstalling Lion would be the best way to determine whether it’s an OS problem or a hardware problem. I have the option to return the computer for an exchange in the first two weeks, so I figured I’d try this. But little did I know just how much of a pain it was.

Since you don’t get a DVD with new Macs, the only way you can reinstall Lion is via the Mac App Store, or the Recovery Partition. Of course, I thought I was smart, when Lion first came out, by putting it on a USB stick, so I could use this for any reinstallation I may need. Alas, when I tried to launch the installer, I was told that it would not work on my Mac mini; presumably the firmware requires something later than 10.7.0.

So, booting from a clone of my startup volume, I launched the App Store and went to download the “update,” which is shown in my Purchases list. That took about two hours, but, when it was completed, the installer was nowhere to be found. When I went back to the App Store application, Lion was listed as “Installed,” so I couldn’t re-download it. Same thing on my MacBook Air, of course, so I was stuck.

So I booted the Mac mini by pressing the Command and R keys, to launch the Recovery Partition. Apparently, mine was borked, so I had to wait a half hour for the computer to download whatever it needed to get to the next step. Then, I launched the installation, and it is now downloading all of Lion; for another, it seems, more than 3 hours. And, when I’ve finished that, I still won’t have an installer, and will have to get one somewhere else, so if I have problems, I don’t have to go through this whole process again.

Frankly, I hadn’t realized how stupid this process is. I can understand the interest of selling Lion through the Mac App Store, but not even providing a boot disc with a new Mac means that any time you have a problem, you have hours of download time. And, since the installer self-destructs after installation, you’ll have to do the same thing if you need another copy of it. (Though the next time there’s a Lion update, I’ll first download a full installer before downloading the update via Software Update.)

I have a fairly fast Internet connection – I get around 650 KBps downloads. But imagine someone with a slower connection, for whom the download will take 6 hours, 8 hours, or even more. Assuming you need to reinstall Lion on a work computer, you’ve lost a day’s work.

Apple conveniently sells a USB stick with an installer, but even if I had one of those, it wouldn’t boot my Mac mini, unless it has the latest version of Lion. And if there’s a future firmware update, it’s possible the $49 USB stick won’t boot either.

I’m appalled by the short-sightedness of this process. Sure, they save on DVDs, but the hassle it causes to users is astounding. I hadn’t realized just how complicated this process was, and, again, having copied the installer to a USB stick, I thought I was safe. How wrong I was.

Update: a developer friend pointed out that you can re-download the installer from the Mac App Store. You need to go to your Purchased list, hold down the Option key, and click on the name of the item. That will take you to its page, where you will see an Install button. You can then click that to download the installer again. I’m doing so now, and will save this one in case of future problems. Thanks Thomas for pointing this out.




14 replies
  1. Bob says:

    I guess I see your point for other hardware, but why would Apple ship a Lion DVD with a Mini when they don’t even have a DVD drive?

    Reply
    • kirk says:

      True. I have an external DVD drive. They should at least provide a USB stick, like they did with the MacBook Air.

      Reply
  2. Arnaud says:

    That would be the reason why I would tend to recommend a clone of latest InstallESD on your internal hard drive instead of Apple Recovery…

    Reply
  3. bert says:

    i don’t know. this seems like someone who is whining without finding out the detail on how to do what he wanted to do in the first place. and complain as he goes along the wrong path.

    Reply
  4. Doug says:

    You are over thinking this. Had you just recovered normally and backed up the Mac mini installer. You would have downloaded once and been fine. I’m not sure what machine you had previously downloaded a copy for but you would have had the same issue had you used it’s installer from a DVD or USB key. Sure having a USB drive pre loaded would be nice but at what price? You seem unwilling to drop the $50 apple wants. But you seem good with $100 cheaper upgrade price.

    Apples system works well if you use it. If you want to out smart it you need to be smarter or willing to spend some money. And by the way .5 to 1.5 mb/sec is crap DSL speeds. Most cable starts at 5-7 and can be as much as 12. Fiber starts at 12 and goes up from there. Hell my iPhone on AT&T can pull 2 mb/sec. So very few people have slower connections than you.

    Reply
    • kirk says:

      I’m not sure I understand your first paragraph… As for the second, you didn’t read very well: I get about 650 KBps, or about 6 Mbps. Sorry, I don’t have fiber; I live on the outskirts of a village in the French Alps. I think it’s a pretty decent connection, actually.

      Reply
  5. Dill says:

    Aha, found a partial source for my comment. I received my Mini (coincidentally the same model and upgrades as yours) on August the 15th, the day before the 10.7.1 update was released, so I remember installing this: http://support.apple.com/kb/DL1439 – I also seem to remember reading somewhere on the Apple discussion boards that LIR had problems “downloading the Mini-specific version of Lion,” so my original statement may still stand. (no source for this one)

    As for SL, instructions for installing it are here: https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3209335 – according to Geekbench, however, SL runs about 75% slower than Lion:
    http://browse.geekbench.ca/geekbench2/view/502416
    and
    http://browse.geekbench.ca/geekbench2/view/488523
    for SL specific examples,
    http://browse.geekbench.ca/geekbench2/search?q=macmini+5%2C2+i7&commit=Search
    for general scores.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply